Jesse J. Prinz is currently distinguished professor at the City University of New Photography of Jesse Prinz Gut reactions: A perceptual theory of emotion. Gut Reactions is an interdisciplinary defense of the claim that emotions are perceptions in a double sense. First of all, they are perceptions of. In his excellent new book, Gut Reactions: A Perceptual Theory of the Emotion, Jesse Prinz challenges this trend for cognitive theories of.


Author: Michelle Crooks
Country: Cameroon
Language: English
Genre: Education
Published: 14 May 2016
Pages: 505
PDF File Size: 11.91 Mb
ePub File Size: 21.23 Mb
ISBN: 381-7-38541-735-5
Downloads: 24949
Price: Free
Uploader: Michelle Crooks


Gut Reactions: A Perceptual Theory of Emotion

Prinz begins by assessing the cognitivism debate. The concept of "cognition" is a sore point in the philosophy of emotion, since there is no consensus and almost no clarity about what it might best mean.

Prinz offers a view as good as any and better than most. He argues that "cognitions are states containing representations that are under [direct] organismic control" This sounds about the same as the view that cognitions are products of the will; but though organismic control or the will is itself mysterious, it is possible to see how one might go about looking gut reactions jesse prinz evidence that a state was answerable to the will.

One can test if a subject can change the state, for example. Furthermore, Prinz goes so far as to brave a hypothesis about the brain areas that may be required for direct control: With this working notion, Prinz concludes that emotions are not cognitive.

Instead, emotions are perceptions of certain kinds of body states. These body states are ones that reliably track certain kinds of conditions in the environment of the agent.

  • Paul E. Griffiths, Jesse Prinz Gut reactions: A perceptual theory of emotion - PhilPapers
  • Gut Reactions - Jesse J. Prinz - Oxford University Press
  • Jesse Prinz — Open MIND
  • Gut Reactions
  • 2005.10.17
  • For more details visit the contributor's

For example, one kind of body state reliably is caused by potential dangers in the environment. An instance of gut reactions jesse prinz is a perception of an instance of this kind of body state.

But because the body state perceived is reliably linked with dangers, it is appropriate to say that fear represents potential dangers in the environment.

To make this distinction, Prinz introduces the terminology of nominal and real contents, so that the nominal content of the emotion as a representation is the body state, but the real content gut reactions jesse prinz the environmental condition that reliably causes the state -- in this case, dangers.

To clarify this point, Prinz uses Anthony Kenny's idea of a formal object. Roughly, the formal object of an emotion is the real and abstracted content of it. Prinz identifies these as core relational themes. The notion of core relational themes is taken from the psychologist Richard Lazarus, who offered a highly intuitive taxonomy of such themes for emotions.

For example, Lazarus identifies "a demeaning offense against me and mine" for anger and "facing an immediate, concrete, and overwhelming physical danger" for fright.

Gut Reactions: A Perceptual Theory of Emotion - Jesse J. Prinz - Google книги

Prinz suggests that the core relational themes of emotions outlined by Lazarus present a highly plausible list of formal objects.

I recommend reading the book for anyone interested in theories of emotion. While we found the arguments to be lacking, the book generated excellent discussion, which I attribute primarily to Prinz's clarity of gut reactions jesse prinz and ability to put forward profound hypotheses in a clear and concise manner.


This is exactly the kind of interdisciplinary work needed for understanding. Will be challenged and perhaps corrected in places esp. Please support us by making your Amazon.

Jesse Prinz

We thank you for your support! Join our e-mail list!: Metapsychology New Review Announcements: Prinz's book gut reactions jesse prinz utterly compelling and a valuable read for any student or researcher of the emotions, philosophy of mind and perception.

His embodied appraisal theory, which attempts to mediate between recent neurobiological approaches and the cognitive theories that have dominated philosophical thinking, is a major step forward in the debate.

Because Prinz builds his case on a richly detailed account of empirical research, I recommend this as the book to gut reactions jesse prinz on the renaissance of emotion in the last two decades, in neuroscience and psychology as well as philosophy. Gordon, University of Missouri, St.

Related Post